23406 AGATHA AVENUE, Punta Gorda, FL 33980

• 3 beds |
• 4 baths |
• 3,031 sqft

Property Description

Rarely does a property combine 1.15 acres across 5-contiguous lots w/ the architectural character, craftsmanship, & outdoor spaces found at this exceptional Port Charlotte estate. 1 mile from I-75, 1/3 mile from Publix, shops & restaurants, & directly across from Harold Avenue Regional Park, the setting offers privacy & everyday convenience. Hospitals, medical services, golf courses & beaches are all within a short drive. Significant major improvements provide exceptional peace of mind: NEW ROOF INSTALLED IN 2026, upgraded Trane XV20i 5-ton variable-speed, 3-zone HVAC system installed in 2023, & a 22kW Generac whole-house LP generator installed in 2017 w/ automatic transfer switch capable of powering the entire electrical system. Additional features include an LP tankless water heater, 2024 water softener, central vacuum, EV charging outlet & underground 500-gallon LP tank. Inspired by Victorian architecture w/ a refined farmhouse flair, the custom residence is defined by details rarely found in today's construction: multiple siding designs, stacked fascia, decorative scroll rafter ends, dimensional shingles w/ copper-penny open diverter valleys & drip edge, slate/stone entry steps, copper-penny roof accents, & an impressive, coffered entry ceiling w/ crown molding & beadboard. A wraparound style porch, IPE decking & breezeway w/ solid cypress beadboard ceilings extend the home's distinctive character. Inside, the craftsmanship continues with 10’ 1st-floor and 9’ 2nd-floor ceilings, vintage hand-finished ¾” solid oak flooring, oak staircase & window sills, oversized solid-core doors, oil-rubbed bronze hardware w/ vintage cut-glass knobs, solid-wood window jambs, custom cased openings & layered crown molding throughout, even the closets. The main level features an expansive foyer w/ sitting area & bay window, living & dining rooms, breakfast area, powder room, & custom kitchen w/ 1” thick cabinet doors, granite countertops, tile backsplash, 36” 6-burner gas cooktop, wood hood, double ovens, warming drawer & 2-pull-out dishwashers. The rear porch & breezeway feature IPE decking, cypress beadboard ceilings, granite counter w/ sink, cabinetry & LP gas grill connection. Upstairs, the primary suite features an angled bay-window sitting area & a beautifully appointed bath w/ marble shower, vintage clawfoot soaking tub, copper sinks, split vanities, stained glass & private water closet. 2 addn'l bedrooms & a well-designed hall bath complete the 2nd floor. The finished, air-conditioned attic adds multiple flexible spaces, custom cabinetry, a large clothing closet & half bath, ideal for an office, studio, hobby space or media room. The 5-lot grounds are a defining feature. 2nd lot is a private park-like retreat w/ mature oaks, multiple sitting areas, fire pit, & more than 250’ of meandering concrete walkways, plus a 50’ RV site with 50-amp electric, water & sewer. 3rd lot includes an 18x33 pool set 2’ into the ground, a 624-square-foot multi-level deck, a 12x24 framed shed matching the home, & a cleared area w/ plans for a proposed 1,276-sqft. 3-car garage w/ loft. 4th lot offers a cleared, park-like setting; 5th is cleared & prepared for a future home pad. Photos can showcase its beauty, but they cannot convey the character, craftsmanship & remarkable sense of place experienced when you walk these grounds & enter this home. Current homeowners’ insurance is $2,432.72 annually; declarations summary available upon request.

Listing Status:

Active

Date Added:

July 8, 2026

Data Last Updated:

September 29, 2026 at 7:23PM

Listing Office:

THOMAS C. MURPHY REAL ESTATE : 941-787-4057

Listing Agent:

Tom Murphy : 941-787-4057

Contact:

941-787-4057

MLS ID:

C7526628

Interior

• General: Ceiling Fans(s)Central VaccumCrown MoldingHigh CeilingsPrimaryBedroom UpstairsStone CountersWalk-In Closet(s)Window Treatments
• Rooms: AtticBreakfast Room SeparateFormal Dining Room SeparateFormal Living Room SeparateInside Utility
• Appliances: Built-In OvenCooktopDishwasherDisposalDryerExhaust FanGas Water HeaterMicrowaveRange HoodTankless Water HeaterWasherWater Softener
• Laundry: Gas Dryer HookupLaundry RoomWasher Hookup
• Flooring: Wood
• A/C: Central AirZonedAttic Fan
• Heating: ElectricHeat Pump

Exterior

• General: Fire PitLightingPrivate YardRV HookupSidewalkStorage
• Style: CustomVictorian
• Other Structures: Finished RV PortShed(s)Front PorchRear PorchCovered
• Pool: Above GroundDeckVinyl
• Parking: BoatDrivewayElectric Vehicle Charging Station(s)Garage Door OpenerGarage Faces SideRV Access/ParkingWorkshop in Garage

Construction

• Roofing: MetalShingle
• Windows: BlindsDouble Pane WindowsInsulated WindowsThermal Windows
• General: StoneWood SidingThree Or MoreCrawlspacePillar/Post/Pier

Location

• Road/Access: Asphalt
• Originating MLS: Stellar MLS
• County: Charlotte

Lot

• Zoning: RSF3.5PORT CHARLOTTE SEC 12 BLK 1589 LT 4 1168/1802 1180/363 2563/1869 PCH 012 1589 0005 PORT CHARLOTTE SEC 12 BLK 1589 LT 5 241/634 DC1160/514 1160/516 1462/199 2576/231 PCH 012 1589 0006 PORT CHARLOTTE SEC 12 BLK 1589 LT 6 408/537 823/17 1008/711 1158/505 1462/210 2576/231 PCH 012 1589 0008 PORT CHARLOTTE SEC12 BLK1589 LT 8 209/205 1695/1326 2376/616 CD2468/834 CD2468/835 CD2468/836 3703/580 TD4245/1841 4353/1958 PCH 012 1589 0007 PORT CHARLOTTE SEC12 BLK1589 LT 7 150/401 1131/212 DC4337/1149-PE 4337/1151402212226007
• View: Park/GreenbeltTrees/Woods
• Fencing: BoardFencedWood

Utilities

• Utilities: BB/HS Internet AvailableCable ConnectedElectricity ConnectedFire HydrantMini SewerPropanePublicSewer ConnectedWater Connected
• Water: Public
• Sewer: Public Sewer

Financial

• Source: Stellar MLS
• Ownership: Fee Simple