2421 PROSPECT STREET, Sarasota, FL 34239

• 3 beds |
• 2 baths |
• 972 sqft

Property Description

Welcome to 2421 Prospect Street in Arlington Park’s Tightly Held RUSTIC LODGE…This Architectural Masterpiece is Rooted in Sarasota’s Golden Era of Homebuilding…the 1950s Marked a Time When Homes Were Designed & Built with Longevity & Craftsmanship—This Residence is a Beautiful Reflection of That Legacy…Approached Not as a Renovation but as a Custom Crafted Rebuild...A Design-Conscious Modern Builder Honored the Original Vision While Elevating the Home to Meet Today’s Expectations for Style, Comfort, and Quality…the Integrity, Proportions, and Character Remain Intact, Now Enhanced by Refined Finishes, Seamlessly Integrated Contemporary Systems, Forward-Thinking Infrastructure, and Improvements Aligned with City of Sarasota Code…Sleek, Clean, and Effortlessly Cool—As Though the 1950s Walked Into 2026 With Style…Expansive New PGT Impact Windows, Sliders, and Doors Bathe the Home in Light While Preserving Energy & Maintaining Tranquility Throughout the Day…Every Detail Has Been Carefully Considered, Including All New Plumbing with Cast Iron Replacement Beneath the Slab, All New Electrical Wiring, HVAC Ductwork, and Engineered Structural Enhancements to Create an Open Floorplan…Level Four+ Walls & Ceilings, Insulated Interior Walls in Key Areas, Freshly Blown Attic Insulation, Tankless Hot Water Heater, Fresh Interior & Exterior Paint, White Oak Plank Flooring with Four-Inch Baseboards, Frameless Glass Shower Doors, Custom Walk-In Closets, and Soft-Close Cabinetry Throughout…Curated Quartz Countertops Extend Across the Gourmet Chef’s Kitchen, Catering Pantry, Dry Bar, and Bathrooms…Additional Home Features Include Custom Tile Backsplashes, Substantial Kitchen Island with Tile Accent Lighting, and Vented Range Hood…Discreetly Integrated Throughout is a Fully Automated Smart Home System Offering Complete Flexibility—Including Remote Entry Keypads, Wireless Alarm, Ring Cameras, Motion Detectors, Panic Buttons, Remote-Control Ceiling Fans, USB & USB-C Outlets, Nest Thermostat, and Digitally Controlled Irrigation—Allowing the Home to Be Fully Automated or Enjoyed Traditionally at the Owner’s Preference…A Fully Screened Lanai with Custom Hardwood Tongue & Groove Ceiling Extends the Living Space Outdoors, Complemented by New Epoxy Flooring Leading to the Paver Patio with Pool, Spa, and Outdoor Living Concepts Available Upon Request…The Grounds Have Been Curated with a Six-Figure Landscape & Lighting Package Featuring Fully Fenced, Double-Gated Privacy, Mature Junipers, Clusia Hedges, Olive Trees, Bird of Paradise, and Fragrant Jasmine…A Three-Bedroom, One-and-a-Half-Bath Residence in the Heart & Soul of Arlington Park—Just Blocks to the Arlington Park & Aquatic Center Where You’ll Find Live Music Events Alongside Pickleball, Tennis, Basketball Courts, Playgrounds, a Dog Park, Walking Trails, and Two Pools…One Mile to Sarasota Memorial Hospital, Minutes From Downtown Sarasota, Siesta Key, Longboat Key, Anna Maria Island, UTC Mall, and a Depth of Dining & Cultural Offerings Favored by Locals…Just a Fifteen-Minute Drive to Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport…Weekly Rentals Are Allowed, Not in a Flood Zone, No Storm Damage Ever, No HOA, and Offered Turn-Key Furnished or Thoughtfully Curated to Buyer Preferences…Passed Down Through Only Two Owners Since the 1950s, This Home Represents Stewardship, Architectural Lineage, and Forward-Thinking Living…It’s Timeless, Intentional, and Unmistakably Rare…Schedule Your Private Tour and Live a Fuller Life!

Listing Status:

Active

Date Added:

January 19, 2026

Data Last Updated:

February 10, 2026 at 3:23PM

Listing Office:

FULLER GROUP : 941-961-3100

Listing Agent:

Bo Fuller : 941-961-3100

MLS ID:

A4677367

Interior

• General: Built-in FeaturesCeiling Fans(s)Dry BarEat-in KitchenLiving Room/Dining Room ComboOpen FloorplanPest Guard SystemPrimary Bedroom Main FloorSmart HomeSolid Wood CabinetsSplit BedroomStone CountersThermostatWalk-In Closet(s)Window Treatments
• Rooms: AtticDen/Library/OfficeInterior In-Law Suite w/No Private Entry
• Appliances: Bar FridgeDishwasherDisposalDryerElectric Water HeaterExhaust FanFreezerIce MakerKitchen Reverse Osmosis SystemMicrowaveOtherRangeRange HoodRefrigeratorTankless Water HeaterWasherWater Filtration SystemWater PurifierWine Refrigerator
• Laundry: Electric Dryer HookupInsideLaundry RoomWasher Hookup
• Flooring: EpoxyLuxury Vinyl
• A/C: Central AirHumidity Control
• Heating: CentralElectricHeat Pump
• Fireplace: Free StandingGasOutsideFireplace
• Eco/Green Feature: AppliancesConstructionDoorsIncentivesInsulationLightingThermostatWater HeaterWindows

Exterior

• General: CourtyardDog RunFire PitGardenLightingMisting SystemOutdoor GrillPermeable PavingPrivate EntrancePrivate MailboxPrivate YardRain GuttersSidewalkSliding Doors
• Style: BungalowCape CodCoastalCraftsmanElevatedFloridaPatio HomeRanchTraditional
• Other Structures: Shed(s)StorageEnclosedPorchRear PorchScreenedPatioCovered
• Parking: CoveredDeededDrivewayOff StreetOn StreetOpenOtherRV Access/Parking

Construction

• Roofing: MembraneShingle
• Windows: BlindsDouble Pane WindowsDrapesENERGY STAR Qualified WindowsInsulated WindowsLow-Emissivity WindowsStorm Window(s)Tinted WindowsWindow TreatmentsWood Frames
• General: AsbestosBlockStuccoFrameOneSlab

Location

• Road/Access: AsphaltPaved
• Originating MLS: Stellar MLS
• County: Sarasota

Lot

• Zoning: RSF4LOT 6 & W 4 FT OF LOT 8 & E 2 FT OF LOT 4 BLK B RUSTIC LODGE NO 22035020094
• View: GardenTrees/Woods
• Fencing: Wood

Utilities

• Utilities: BB/HS Internet AvailableCable ConnectedElectricity ConnectedFiber OpticsPhone AvailablePublicSewer ConnectedUnderground UtilitiesWater Connected
• Water: Public
• Sewer: Public Sewer

Financial

• Source: Stellar MLS
• Ownership: Fee Simple