5401 N Illinois Street, Indianapolis, IN 46208

• 4 beds |
• 4 baths |
• 3,311 sqft

Property Description

This classic 1933 Colonial beautifully embodies the charm and character of Butler-Tarkington. From the wide front porch and white picket fence to the parquet floors, custom lighting, and bespoke window treatments, every detail reflects timeless style. A gracious entry welcomes you with a striking two-story foyer and elegant curved staircase, setting the tone for the home's refined interiors. The formal dining room flows seamlessly into a thoughtfully renovated kitchen, showcasing marble countertops and backsplash, premium Jenn-Air and Bosch appliances, including 2 ovens, 2 dishwashers, and a free-standing ice machine, and easy access to a functional mudroom and attached two-car garage. The main level also features a formal living room anchored by a cozy wood-burning fireplace with access to the covered front porch, along with an inviting den highlighted by custom built-ins. Upstairs, the spacious primary suite offers two closets and a beautifully renovated and appointed ensuite bath with a walk-in shower, garden tub, and dual vanities. Two additional generously sized bedrooms and a recently renovated hall bath complete the upper level. Rare for this historic neighborhood, the finished lower level provides a comfortable family room, fourth bedroom, and renovated powder bath-ideal for entertaining or hosting overnight guests. Located just blocks from the shops and restaurants at 56th & Illinois and surrounded by nearby parks and playgrounds, this home offers an exceptional lifestyle in a highly sought-after setting. With so many remarkable features to admire, this is a property that truly must be experienced in person.

Listing Status:

Pending

Data Last Updated:

February 16, 2026 at 12:19PM

Listing Office:

F.C. Tucker Company : 317-590-0529

Listing Agent:

Matt McLaughlin : 317-590-0529

MLS ID:

22080429

Interior

• General: Bath Sinks Double MainBreakfast BarEntrance FoyerPaddle FanHardwood FloorsHi-Speed Internet AvailblWalk-In Closet(s)WoodWorkStain/Painted
• Appliances: DishwasherDryerDisposalMicrowaveGas OvenRefrigeratorWasherWater HeaterWater PurifierWater Softener Owned
• Basement: Egress Window(s)Exterior EntryPartially Finished
• A/C: Central Air
• Heating: Forced Air
• Fireplace: BasementLiving RoomWood BurningFireplaces: 2

Exterior

• Style: Colonial
• Other Structures: Covered
• Parking: AttachedConcreteGarage Door Opener

Construction

• General: TwoConcrete Perimeter

Location

• Originating MLS: mibor
• School District: Indianapolis Public Schools
• County: Marion

Lot

• Zoning: A B Carter's 1st Add 53.45Ft X 147Ft Sw Corl26490612232033000801
• Fencing: Front Yard

Utilities

• Water: Public

Financial

• Source: mibor