5456 Oliver Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46241

Property Description

Duplex home is a money making opportunity, or ... owner may live in one side while the other side makes the mortgage payment. 1450 SF total, split equally into 2 units, 725 SF/ea. Both have 2-BR, 1-bath with tub/shower, baseboard elec heat, A/C wall unit, and a whole house attic fan. Structurally, the property is in great shape with stone veneer, slab foundation and a recent new roof. Large 8' x 50' (400 SF) covered front porch and an 8' s 46' (368 SF) back patio. Cosmetically, it needs a little love to shine again. Kitchen cabinets are good, bathtubs are good ... just needs deep clean, paint, flooring, appliances and fixtures. There is a huge detached garage (28' x 40' or 1128 SF) which could be shared or assigned to the 5458 side unit. It has a 2-car garage door and is more than 4 cars in total size. Garage has heat and a circuit breaker box and needs hooked again to power from the pole. We're thinking the left side with garage would rent for $1000/mo while the right side would be $800/mo.

Listing Status:

Active

Data Last Updated:

May 20, 2026 at 2:19AM

Listing Office:

Jeneene West Realty, LLC : 317-856-4719

Listing Agent:

Jeneene West : 317-856-4719

MLS ID:

22102869

Interior

• A/C: Wall Unit(s)Whole House Fan
• Heating: BaseboardElectric

Exterior

• Style: Ranch
• Parking: Detached

Construction

• Roofing: Asphalt
• General: OneSlab

Location

• Road/Access: City Street
• Originating MLS: mibor
• School District: MSD Wayne Township
• County: Marion

Lot

• Zoning: Cloverleaf Farms First Section L 5491212113010000930
• Fencing: Partial
• Current Use: Residential

Financial

• Source: mibor