17--19 W DELAWARE AVE, Pennington, NJ 08534

Property Description

Rare opportunity to own a well-maintained 5-unit multifamily in the heart of downtown Pennington Borough, one of Mercer County's most desirable small communities. This character-filled older building features a balanced unit mix of two 2-bedroom and three 1-bedroom apartments, offering the kind of old-world charm that distinguishes it from newer cookie-cutter construction. The current owner has made targeted capital investments where it counts most, including a new roof, upgraded electrical systems, solar panels, and renovated kitchens, significantly reducing near-term capital expenditure risk for a new owner without over-improving the asset. Trailing 12-month gross revenue of $106,486 and a net operating income of $69,402 reflect a clean, well-run operation with a lean 34.8% expense ratio. The property offers compelling upside for the right buyer: in-place rents show room for organic growth of approximately $900/month based on rents already being achieved within the building, and an existing third-floor storage space presents a conversion opportunity to create a 6th income-producing unit at an estimated $1,500/month, combining for approximately $400,000 in additional asset value at a 7% cap rate. Municipal parking directly behind the building and plentiful street parking support long-term tenant demand and retention. Pennington Borough offers top-rated schools, walkable downtown amenities, and convenient access to Route 31, I-95, and I-295, consistently attracting quality, long-term tenants. Ideal for a self-managing investor, 1031 exchange buyer, or value-add operator looking for a cash-flowing asset with real upside in a premier Central New Jersey location. Listed at $1,175,000, priced on actual in-place performance.

Listing Status:

Active

Data Last Updated:

June 24, 2026 at 2:19AM

Listing Office:

Estately Inc : 2066241372

Listing Agent:

Darren Griffith : 2066241372

MLS ID:

NJME2076994

Interior

• A/C: Window Unit(s)
• Heating: Baseboard - ElectricSolar - ActiveBaseboard - Hot WaterElectricNatural Gas
• Disability Feature: None

Construction

• Roofing: AsphaltShingle
• General: Vinyl SidingStick BuiltFrame

Location

• Originating MLS: BRIGHT_MAIN
• School District: HOPEWELL VALLEY REGIONAL SCHOOLS
• County: MERCER-NJ

Lot

• Zoning: B-R08-00205-00029

Utilities

• Water: Public
• Sewer: No Septic System

Financial

• Source: BRIGHT_MAIN