5657 Broadway Street, Lancaster, NY 14086

• 3 beds |
• 2 baths |
• 1,860 sqft

Property Description

Welcome to this well-maintained upper/lower duplex located on the edge of the historic Village of Lancaster! Owned by the same seller since 1991, this property reflects years of pride in ownership and thoughtful updates throughout. A fantastic opportunity for owner-occupants, investors, or multi-generational living! The lower 2 bedroom unit offers a very efficient layout featuring a spacious living room with front door access to the deck, formal dining room, entryway, galley kitchen with the stove and refrigerator included, 2 comfortable bedrooms, 1 full bathroom and side entry hall perfect for mudroom space with coat hooks and basement access. The long-term lower tenant has occupied the unit for over a decade! The vacant upper unit features beautiful hardwood floors, rustic details and a versatile open-concept layout with room for a sectional or office setup. The galley kitchen includes a built-in breakfast bar and stove. Upstairs also offers 1 large bedroom, 1 full bathroom and private balcony space to enjoy the outdoors. Each unit has separate utilities, separate laundry hookups and separate generators! All mechanics / both furnaces have been on a yearly maintenance plan with Capital Heat for several years. Outside, enjoy off-street parking with turnaround space near the detached 2-car garage, set away from the road and ideal for storage. Seller also invested in a large privacy fence along the paved driveway for added seclusion and functionality. Conveniently located near village amenities, shops, restaurants and commuter routes while still offering a charming historic setting. A rare duplex opportunity in Lancaster with flexibility, character and long-term value! This is the most MOVE-IN- READY multi-family home you have seen this season!!

Listing Status:

Pending

Date Added:

May 26, 2026

Data Last Updated:

June 26, 2026 at 1:18AM

Listing Office:

HUNT Real Estate Corporation : 716-652-1234

Listing Agent:

Sarah Kieffer : 716-512-3806

MLS ID:

B1682070

Interior

• General: Ceiling Fan(s)
• Appliances: Gas Water Heater
• Laundry: Washer Hookup
• Basement: Full
• Flooring: CarpetHardwoodVariesVinyl
• Heating: GasForced Air
• Fireplace: Fireplaces: 0

Exterior

• General: BalconyDeckFence
• Style: Duplex
• Other Structures: PorchBalconyDeckOpen
• Parking: Parking AvailableTwo or More Spaces

Construction

• Roofing: AsphaltFlat
• General: Vinyl SidingCopper Plumbing2Stone

Location

• Road/Access: City Street
• Originating MLS: NYS_B
• School District: Lancaster
• County: Erie

Lot

• Zoning: 145203-115-280-0003-002-000
• Fencing: Partial

Utilities

• Utilities: Cable AvailableHigh Speed Internet AvailableSewer ConnectedWater ConnectedCircuit Breakers
• Water: ConnectedPublic
• Sewer: Connected

Financial

• Source: NYS_B