1274 HERKIMER Street, New York City, NY 11233

• 5 beds |
• 3 baths |
• 2,150 sqft

Property Description

Key Details: - Two-family brick townhouse - 5 bedrooms 3 full bathrooms - 2,150 SF interior - Solid structure with well-maintained mechanicals and bones - Delivered in clean, livable condition with opportunity to update - Five decorative fireplaces throughout - Unfinished but clean basement with flexible use potential - On the same block as the Rockaway Ave - C train - Strong income potential with projected rents exceeding $4,000+ Flexible layout-maintain as a two-family or explore conversion to 4 units (consult architect) Located in the rapidly evolving Ocean Hill section of Brooklyn, 1274 Herkimer Street presents a rare opportunity to acquire a classic brick townhouse with scale, character, and long-term upside. Spanning approximately 2,150 square feet, this two-family property is currently configured with five bedrooms and three full bathrooms, offering a versatile layout suited for both end-users and investors. The home has been well maintained over the years and offers solid bones throughout, making it an ideal candidate for a thoughtful cosmetic renovation. Period charm is evident with five decorative fireplaces that anchor multiple living spaces, adding warmth and architectural interest. Generous room proportions allow for king-sized bedrooms and flexible living arrangements across both units. The basement is clean and expansive, currently unfinished but primed for conversion into a home office, recreation space, or additional storage depending on your needs. Above grade, the layout lends itself to multiple strategies-continue operating as a two-family with strong rental income, or explore reconfiguration into a higher-yield multi-unit investment (subject to approvals). Positioned literally on the corner of Rockaway Avenue, the C train provides direct and efficient access into Manhattan, making commuting seamless. Flanked by Bed Stuy, the surrounding neighborhood continues to see steady growth, with increasing demand from renters and buyers alike drawn to its accessibility through Broadway Junction and value relative to neighboring areas. Whether you're looking to create a custom residence with income, capitalize on rental upside, or reposition the asset entirely, 1274 Herkimer Street offers the foundation to execute your vision.

Listing Status:

Active

Date Added:

May 8, 2026

Data Last Updated:

June 12, 2026 at 7:19AM

Listing Office:

Brown Harris Stevens Brooklyn LLC : 718-613-2780

Listing Agent:

Isaiah Ajala : (719) 399-4166

MLS ID:

RLS20094278

Interior

• General: Smoke Free
• Laundry: In Unit
• Basement: Other
• A/C: None

Exterior

• General: Private Outdoor Space Under 60 Sqft
• Style: Walk-Up

Construction

• General: 2

Location

• Originating MLS: RLS_REBNY
• County: Kings

Lot

• Zoning: 01567-0021
• View: OtherView

Financial

• Source: RLS_REBNY