5 Spring Garden Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

• 5 beds |
• 3 baths |
• 2,845 sqft

Property Description

Steeped in history and timeless architectural charm, this rare circa-1872 Gothic Revival cottage is located within the historic district of Shelter Island Heights, listed on both the National and New York State Registers of Historic Places. Beautifully preserved and largely unchanged since its original design, the home is a remarkable example of the picturesque residential style created by America’s earliest landscape architects. Originally described as a “2.5-story Gothic Revival cottage with hipped roof, segmental arch window heads and two-tier veranda,” the residence retains an extraordinary collection of original details rarely found today. Highlights include 39 original working double-hung windows complete with storms and screens, four original attic “cross-breeze” windows designed to naturally cool the home, original solid oak interior and exterior doors, spacious 10-foot ceilings, and plaster walls throughout the main house. Three spacious front bedrooms — including the primary — open directly onto a covered second-story wraparound sleeping porch, capturing the breezes and relaxed elegance of Shelter Island summers. Cottage-style clapboard accents in the kitchen and rear bedroom add warmth and authenticity to the historic interiors. Thoughtful infrastructure improvements complement the home’s historic integrity, including a new roof (2006), a newly excavated full-footprint extra-deep basement with radiant heat slab (2008), and a complete rebuild of the secondary upstairs bath (2010). The property may also qualify for the New York State Historic Homeownership Rehabilitation Credit Program, offering a potential tax credit on qualified rehabilitation expenditures. A truly special opportunity to own an architecturally significant home in one of New York’s most cherished historic communities.

Listing Status:

Active

Data Last Updated:

June 26, 2026 at 5:22PM

Listing Office:

Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty : 631-749-1155

MLS ID:

1004894

Interior

• General: Formal DiningHigh CeilingsOriginal DetailsPantryPrimary BathroomSoaking Tub
• Appliances: DryerRefrigeratorWasher
• Basement: Bilco Door(s)FullStorage SpaceUnfinished
• A/C: Multi Units
• Heating: Propane
• Fireplace: Family RoomFireplaceFireplaces: 1

Exterior

• Style: Victorian
• Other Structures: Shed(s)
• Parking: Driveway

Location

• HOA Amenities: SewerWater6466.0Annually
• Originating MLS: onekey2
• School District: Shelter Island
• County: Suffolk County

Lot

• Zoning: 0700-005-00-04-00-023-000
• View: NeighborhoodPanoramic

Utilities

• Utilities: Electricity ConnectedSewer ConnectedWater Connected
• Water: Public
• Sewer: Public Sewer

Financial

• Source: onekey2