3400 Youngs Avenue, Southold, NY 11971
- 4 beds |
- 2 baths |
- 2,000 sqft
Rental 
Built in 1839 
—— sqft lot 
—— car garage 
$4/sqft 
Listed 3 years ago
Property Description
Nobody comes to the North Fork because they're looking for excitement, they come because they're looking for something they've been missing. Time slows here. Not dramatically, but quietly. You notice it on the first morning when you realize you've finished your coffee without checking your phone. The windows are open, the breeze carries the scent of nearby fields, and the only thing on the agenda is deciding whether today is a beach day, a winery day, or a day that never really leaves the backyard. Children pop in the pool before breakfast, someone wanders to the farm stand for fresh fruit and warm pie. Lunch stretches into the afternoon because nobody is in a hurry. The grill comes on long before dinner, and another bottle somehow finds its way onto the table. As the sun settles behind the trees, the landscape lights quietly illuminate the yard. Conversations become stories. Stories become laughter. Nobody remembers what time it is. Tomorrow can wait. Not just because of four spacious bedrooms or a beautiful heated saltwater pool, but rather because it offers the feeling that summer used to have when you were young. The farmhouse has stood proud since 1839, thoughtfully restored for modern living while keeping the character that makes old homes feel lived in, rather than designed. The pool house becomes the afternoon headquarters. The lawn is big enough for every game that somehow starts with "just one round." The porch earns its place every morning and every evening. And when you decide to venture out, some of the North Fork's best beaches, wineries, farm stands, marinas, and villages are only minutes away. By the second day, it already feels like home.
- Listing Status:
- Active
- Data Last Updated:
- August 12, 2026 at 3:22AM
- Listing Office:
- Thomas J McCarthy Real Estate : tmccarthy.tmccarthy@gmail.com
- MLS ID:
- L3489027
- General: Gas Grill
- Style: Farmhouse
- Other Structures: OutbuildingPorchDeckPatio
- Pool: In Ground
- Parking: DrivewayOff StreetPrivate
- Windows: Double Pane WindowsInsulated WindowsBlindsDrapesScreens
- General: Two
- Originating MLS: onekey2
- School District: Southold
- County: Suffolk County
- View: PanoramicOpen
- Fencing: Back YardFenced
- Water: Public
- Sewer: Cesspool
- Source: onekey2
This listing courtesy of Thomas J McCarthy Real Estate
