731 PENNSYLVANIA AVE, York, PA 17404

• 2,206 sqft

Property Description

731 Pennsylvania Ave is the type of property that tends to catch the attention of both investors and house hackers in York. Located in The Avenues, one of the city’s most recognizable and consistently sought-after rental areas, this duplex sits in a spot where tenants genuinely want to live. The property currently produces $1,772 per month in rental income and includes two units. The upper unit is already in great condition, while the lower unit provides a clear path to add value with simple updates. There is also a garage, which is a feature renters in the city appreciate for parking, storage, or both. Part of what makes this property appealing is its location within The Avenues of York, a historic neighborhood known for its tree-lined streets, classic homes, and close connection to downtown. Residents enjoy being just minutes from many of the places that make York an active and growing city. Central Market York, WellSpan Park (home of the York Revolution), and the Appell Center for the Performing Arts are all nearby, along with a growing selection of restaurants, coffee shops, breweries, and local gathering spots. Popular destinations like Revival Social Club, The Left Bank Restaurant, and Tutoni’s are within easy reach, while coffee stops like Prince Street Cafe and everyday grocery options such as Weis Markets and Giant make daily living convenient. Commuting from here is straightforward. Pennsylvania Ave provides quick access to Route 30, one of York’s main east-west routes, as well as Interstate 83, which connects north to Harrisburg and south toward Maryland and the Baltimore area. Route 74 is also nearby, making it easy to move across the city. Because of these connections, the location attracts renters who work throughout York County or commute to nearby areas like Lancaster, Hanover, or Harrisburg. Another driver of rental demand in this area is its proximity to major employers. York College of Pennsylvania and WellSpan York Hospital are both only minutes away, bringing steady demand from students, medical staff, and employees who want to live close to work while still being near downtown amenities. For investors, the opportunity is straightforward: a duplex in The Avenues with current income already in place and a clear path to increase rents through light improvements. For house hackers, it’s an equally practical setup, live in one unit, update the other, and let the rental income help offset a large portion of the mortgage while owning property in one of York’s most consistently desirable rental neighborhoods.

Listing Status:

Pending

Date Added:

March 18, 2026

Data Last Updated:

April 2, 2026 at 6:16AM

Listing Office:

EXP Realty, LLC : 8883977352

Listing Agent:

Nathaniel Martin Barshinger : 7176684694

MLS ID:

PAYK2098788

Interior

• A/C: Window Unit(s)
• Heating: Hot WaterCentralNatural Gas
• Disability Feature: None

Exterior

• General: Above GradeBelow Grade
• Style: Colonial

Construction

• General: BrickPermanent

Location

• Originating MLS: BRIGHT_MAIN
• School District: YORK CITY
• County: YORK-PA

Lot

• Zoning: 122 R – TWO FAMILY RESIDE14-481-12-0014-00-00000

Utilities

• Water: Public
• Sewer: Public Sewer

Financial

• Source: BRIGHT_MAIN
• Exclusions: Tenant's personal items