64A N Midway Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

• 5 beds |
• 4 baths |
• 2,642 sqft

Property Description

A rare turnkey Shelter Island retreat with two distinct homes tucked away on nearly an acre in the heart of Shelter Island, 64A North Midway Road presents a truly unique opportunity to own two homes on one private property. Surrounded by mature trees, expansive lawns, and a picturesque pond next door, this exceptional estate blends privacy, flexibility, and timeless charm. This rare property offers remarkable versatility to fit your lifestyle. The welcoming ranch-style main home offers a comfortable living space with 3 bedrooms and two full bathrooms. A spacious kitchen with abundant cabinetry flows seamlessly into the dining area, creating an inviting setting for everyday living and entertaining. The living room, anchored by a wood-burning fireplace, provides a warm and cozy gathering place throughout the seasons. Step outside to the expansive rear deck, complete with a hot tub overlooking a large, private backyard with room for a pool, an ideal setting for entertaining, relaxing, or enjoying peaceful evenings. A welcoming front porch, an attached one-car garage, and a carport. Privately positioned toward the rear of the property, the stunning barn-style home feels like a secluded retreat. Overlooking a tranquil pond, this approx. The residence is filled with warmth, character, and natural light. The dramatic main room features soaring vaulted ceilings with exposed beams, a gas fireplace, and an impressive wall of windows that captures beautiful views while flooding the home with sunshine. French doors that open onto an expansive 500 square foot mahogany deck with built-in storage, creating the perfect place to enjoy morning coffee, outdoor dining, or simply unwind. The barn home also features two spacious bedrooms, two full bathrooms, a large loft, and a well-appointed kitchen. The oversized lower-level garage offers exceptional storage for vehicles, recreational equipment, bicycles, tools, and more, while additional facilities and energy-efficient solar panels further enhance the home’s appeal. The beautifully landscaped .95 acre property provides an uncommon sense of privacy while remaining just minutes from the Shelter Island beaches, marinas, restaurants, shops, farm stands, and nature preserve. 64A North Midway Road offers possibilities that are rarely available on Shelter Island.

Listing Status:

Active

Data Last Updated:

August 11, 2026 at 7:23PM

Listing Office:

Douglas Elliman Real Estate : 631-354-8100

MLS ID:

1029569

Interior

• General: First Floor BedroomFirst Floor Full BathBeamed CeilingsCathedral Ceiling(s)Ceiling Fan(s)Central VacuumCrown MoldingEat-in KitchenGranite CountersHigh CeilingsOpen FloorplanOpen KitchenPantryPrimary BathroomRecessed LightingSoaking TubStorageWalk Through Kitchen
• Appliances: Convection OvenDishwasherDryerElectric CooktopElectric RangeElectric Water HeaterExhaust FanFreezerMicrowaveRefrigeratorStainless Steel Appliance(s)WasherTankless Water Heater
• Basement: Bilco Door(s)Full
• Flooring: Ceramic TileCombinationHardwood
• A/C: Central Air
• Heating: DuctsForced AirHot WaterOil
• Fireplace: GasLiving RoomMasonryWood BurningFireplace

Exterior

• Style: BarndominiumRanch
• Other Structures: Residence
• Parking: Private

Location

• Originating MLS: onekey2
• School District: Shelter Island
• County: Suffolk County

Lot

• Zoning: 0700-014-00-04-00-007-004

Utilities

• Utilities: Electricity ConnectedPhone ConnectedPropaneWater Connected
• Water: Well
• Sewer: Septic Tank

Financial

• Source: onekey2